Tue . 20 Aug 2020
TR | RU | UK | KK | BE |

Possession is nine-tenths of the law

possession is nine-tenths of the law, possession is nine-tenths of the lawn
Possession is nine-tenths of the law is an expression meaning that ownership is easier to maintain if one has possession of something, or difficult to enforce if one does not The expression is also stated as "possession is nine points of the law", which is credited as derived from the Scottish expression "possession is eleven points in the law, and they say there are but twelve"[1]

Although the principle is an oversimplification, it can be restated as: "In a property dispute whether real or personal, in the absence of clear and compelling testimony or documentation to the contrary, the person in actual, custodial possession of the property is presumed to be the rightful owner The rightful owner shall have their possession returned to them; if taken or used The shirt or blouse you are currently wearing is presumed to be yours, unless someone can prove that it is not"[2]

Contents

  • 1 Analysis
    • 11 Cases
  • 2 See also
  • 3 References

Analysis

The adage is not literally true, that by law the person in possession is presumed to have a nine times stronger claim than anyone else, but that "it places in a strong light the legal truth that every claimant must succeed by the strength of his own title, and not by the weakness of his antagonist's"[3] The principle bears some similarity to uti possidetis "as you possess, so may you continue to possess", which currently refers to the doctrine that colonial administrative boundaries become international boundaries when a political subdivision or colony achieves independence Under Roman law, it was an interdictum ordering the parties to maintain possession of property until it was determined who owned the property[4]

Cases

In the Hatfield-McCoy feud, with testimony evenly divided, the doctrine that possession is nine-tenths of the law caused Floyd Hatfield to retain possession of the pig that the McCoys claimed was their property[5] It has been argued that in some situations, possession is ten-tenths of the law[6] While the concept is older, the phrase "Possession is nine-tenths of the law" is often claimed to date from the 16th century[7] In some countries, possession is not nine-tenths of the law, but rather the onus is on the possessor to substantiate his ownership[8]

This concept has been applied to both tangible and intangible products[9] In particular, "knowledge management" presents problems with regard to this principle[10] Google's possession of a large amount of content has been the cause of some wariness due to this principle[11] It has been said that there was a time in which the attitude towards rights over genetic resources was that possession is nine tenths of the law, and for the other tenth reliance could be made on the principle that biological resources were the heritage of mankind[12]

Aboriginal people frequently encounter this principle[13] There is some question as to whether the principle applies to Native American land claims[14][15] It has been said that “squatter's rights” and “possession is 9/10ths of the law” were largely responsible for how the American West was really won[16]

See also

  • Adverse possession
  • Conversion law
  • Finders keepers
  • Homesteading
  • Might makes right

References

  1. ^ Albert M Martin 1882 "Answers" The Chautauquan Chautauqua Literary and Scientific Circle 3 October 1882mw-parser-output citecitationmw-parser-output citation qmw-parser-output id-lock-free a,mw-parser-output citation cs1-lock-free amw-parser-output id-lock-limited a,mw-parser-output id-lock-registration a,mw-parser-output citation cs1-lock-limited a,mw-parser-output citation cs1-lock-registration amw-parser-output id-lock-subscription a,mw-parser-output citation cs1-lock-subscription amw-parser-output cs1-subscription,mw-parser-output cs1-registrationmw-parser-output cs1-subscription span,mw-parser-output cs1-registration spanmw-parser-output cs1-ws-icon amw-parser-output codecs1-codemw-parser-output cs1-hidden-errormw-parser-output cs1-visible-errormw-parser-output cs1-maintmw-parser-output cs1-subscription,mw-parser-output cs1-registration,mw-parser-output cs1-formatmw-parser-output cs1-kern-left,mw-parser-output cs1-kern-wl-leftmw-parser-output cs1-kern-right,mw-parser-output cs1-kern-wl-right
  2. ^ S Rutledge 2000, Government's defense of the Status Quo: Advocating a shift in applying presumption theory in intercollegiate parliamentary debate PDF, Parliamentary Debate
  3. ^ Horrell, Drew FT 1991, Telepossession in Nine-Tenths of the Law: The Emerging Industry of Deep Ocean Discovery, 3, Pace YB Int'l L, p 309
  4. ^ Duncan, John 2007, Uti Possidetis: Is Possession Really Nine-Tenths of the Law - The Acquisition of Territory by the United States: Why, How, and Should We, 38, McGeorge L Rev, p 513
  5. ^ Karen Grover Duffy; James W Grosch; Paul V Olczak 1991 Community Mediation: A Handbook for Practitioners and Researchers p 3 ISBN 9780898625615
  6. ^ E Bentley 1966, "An Un-American Chalk Circle", The Tulane Drama Review, 10 4: 64–77, doi:102307/1125210, JSTOR 1125210
  7. ^ AL Erickson 2007, Possession—and the other one-tenth of the law: assessing women's ownership and economic roles in early modern England PDF, Womenʼs History Review
  8. ^ T Shaw 1997, "The contemporary plundering of Africa's past", African Archaeological Review, 14: 1–7, doi:101007/BF02968363
  9. ^ Eymard, Frank C December 1, 2003, Possession is 9/10ths of the Law, Chemical Engineering Progress
  10. ^ Boisot, M; Griffiths, D 1999, Possession is nine tenths of the law: managing a firm's knowledge base in a regime of weak appropriability PDF, International Journal of Technology
  11. ^ LS BeDell; D Greenstein; M Sandler; A Wise 2006, Scholarship and Libraries in Transition: Panel Session-Publishing PDF
  12. ^ D Cunningham; B Tobin; K Watanabe 2004, Tracking genetic resources and international access and benefit sharing governance: The role of certificates of origin, United Nations University
  13. ^ Henrietta Fourmile 1990, Possession is nine-tenths of the law — and don't Aboriginal people know it, Bulletin of the Conference of Museum Anthropologists
  14. ^ I Starr 1993, Law in United States History: A Kaleidoscopic View, The, Update on L Related Educ
  15. ^ JW Singer 2005, Nine-Tenths of the Law: Title, Possession & and Sacred Obligations, Conn L Rev
  16. ^ J Tanner, Running Head: The Power of Place

possession is nine-tenths of the law, possession is nine-tenths of the law 2017, possession is nine-tenths of the law act, possession is nine-tenths of the law enforcement, possession is nine-tenths of the law firm, possession is nine-tenths of the lawn, possession is nine-tenths of the lawn mower, possession is nine-tenths of the lawrence, possession is nine-tenths of the laws, possession is nine-tenths of the lawyer


Possession is nine-tenths of the law Information about

Possession is nine-tenths of the law


  • user icon

    Possession is nine-tenths of the law beatiful post thanks!

    29.10.2014


Possession is nine-tenths of the law
Possession is nine-tenths of the law
Possession is nine-tenths of the law viewing the topic.
Possession is nine-tenths of the law what, Possession is nine-tenths of the law who, Possession is nine-tenths of the law explanation

There are excerpts from wikipedia on this article and video

Random Posts

Picts

Picts

The Picts were a tribal confederation of peoples who lived in what is today eastern and northern Sco...
Visual prosthesis

Visual prosthesis

A visual prosthesis, often referred to as a bionic eye, is an experimental visual device intended to...
Mini rugby

Mini rugby

Mini rugby, also known as New Image Rugby, is a form of rugby union designed to introduce the sport ...
List of synthetic polymers

List of synthetic polymers

Synthetic polymers are human-made polymers From the utility point of view they can be classified int...